Ninni Pacifier Onyx 4 Pack

The Onyx color is even better in person—deep and sleek, so it doesn't clash with anything I put my baby in. Having four on hand means I can rotate them through the dishwasher without ever scrambling for a clean one mid-cry.

We grabbed the 4-pack so we’d always have one within arm’s reach, and the matte black works with every outfit we’ve tried. The bold hue actually looks sharper in person than it did on screen, and swapping them out between uses has been a lifesaver.

The matte black finish on these looks way more expensive than they probably were, and I love that they blend with literally everything in the diaper bag. With four in rotation, I never have to scramble at 3 a.m. when one hits the floor.